minds, metaphors and (ethical) manipulation
How to get people to trust you
I’ve been blogging recently about the relationship between words, physical actions, metaphor and influence.
One expert who really “gets” this, who I had the privilege of meeting recently, is Mark Bowden, author of Winning Body Language.
Let me share my biggest takeaway from the many useful things he taught me. It’s something I started using straight away and, based on my results, I’m not about to stop any time soon!
Mark says: “The following simple piece of body language, hundreds of thousands of years old and still applicable today, is totally overlooked in understanding by nonverbal communication “experts” and business presentation trainers around the globe. It has, however, been handed down within the community of visual communicators for centuries. Until this point, it has never been put in writing for any business audience…
“So here is that signal that instantly lets the members of an audience know that you are genuine in intention and can be trusted: Gestures on a horizontal plane extending from the navel.”
Mark calls this horizontal plane the TruthPlane and adds:
“When the hands gesture within the TruthPlane, an energized calm, confident and balanced effect is felt by both the communicator and the receiver.”
And: “Across all cultures and at all times, it is the strongest symbol for ‘You can trust me’.”
It’s a powerful insight: easy to understand, easy to use. Try it!
(I’d love to hear how it worked for you in the “comments” section below.)
Metaphor and the TruthPlane
The TruthPlane technique is useful in many ways. It’s great to have an extra way to get people to trust you – while incidentally calming any public speaking nerves.
And the TruthPlane is also an interesting example of the relationship between physical actions, metaphor and influence – without words.
- The action of gesturing in the TruthPlane influences both the actor and the audience.
- Metaphor “carries” the message, at an unconscious level.
- For the actor, the action is a metaphor for “energized calm, confident and balanced”. As they make the action, they feel the feeling.
- For the audience, the same action is a universal metaphor for ‘You can trust me’. As they see the action, they feel the feeling.
- Neither actor nor audience needs to be consciously aware of the TruthPlane gestures in order to feel the effects. It’s all happening at an unconscious level and so just works.
Advanced exercise: Mark suggests doing contrasting versions of Jamie Smart’s Pizza Walk, gesturing either in the TruthPlane or with your hands down at your sides.
| Print article | This entry was posted by Judy on 18/04/2011 at 12:32 pm, and is filed under Body-Mind, Influence, Metaphor, The Mind. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |
No trackbacks yet.
What Is Clean Language?
about 5 months ago - 1 comment
I talk a lot about Clean Language on this blog. But you may be wondering what Clean Language is, and why it’s interesting. So (thanks to a nudge from a friend on Facebook) I’ve decided it’s time for a few short introductory YouTube videos. Here’s the first one: If you prefer to read your introduction,
“This will have a very profound effect”
about 8 months ago - No comments
Peter Wright’s very kind review of my brand-new video, The Mind Readers’ Guide To Metaphor Part 1: Hearing Hidden Metaphors, is below. Look out! The video will be published any day now. Sneak peek here Metaphor is all around us. And it’s our most widely used form of language born, as it is, out of
Leveraging the Unconscious Mind
about 10 months ago - 1 comment
At least 95 per cent of “thinking” occurs outside our conscious awareness. All kinds of things are going on in our bodies, and in the shadows of our brains, that we’ll never become aware of. And this unconscious processing is, to a large extent, what drives our behaviours. As Daniel Wenger puts it in The Illusion
Clean Language: Hypnosis Without Trance?
about 10 months ago - 18 comments
My good friend James Tripp is riding high at the moment: his latest Hypnosis Without Trance product sold out in minutes! I knew James included lots of Clean Language ideas in his work. But I hadn’t spotted the references to “trance without induction” in David Grove’s only published book until I re-read on a flight it
Why Don’t You Ask More Questions?
about 11 months ago - No comments
Why don’t you ask more questions? It’s a question that’s been nagging me for a while, as I’ve been busy both exhorting people to do more asking – for example, in this video – and training people to ask specific kinds of questions. And (doh!) one possible answer has just struck me. Presumably, something’s stopping
Are Second-Hand Metaphors Restricting Your Life?
about 1 year ago - 4 comments
Are you living your life according to your own metaphors? Or is your system being restricted by ill-fitting second-hand ideas, images and connections? As I’ve mentioned frequently in this blog, the metaphors you use in your thinking (including your subconscious processing) have a profound impact on your behaviour. It’s inevitable, because metaphor is the language
Influence: actions speak louder than words
about 1 year ago - 2 comments
Influential language is important. Questions, listening and metaphor are important. But there could be an even more important factor in influence: the purely “incidental” behaviour of the people around you. “Turns out your colleague’s husband’s sister can make you fat, even if you’ve never met. And a happy friend affects your happiness more than a
Your great sales pitch
about 1 year ago - No comments
We were discussing what “passive income” means – and whether it can damage your health – when news came through that a friend had the chance to “pitch” his idea to one of the Dragons from Dragons Den. Well done to Trine for that! And it got me wondering about the metaphors involved in “pitching”.
Infectious metaphors
about 1 year ago - 6 comments
As I mentioned recently, the habit of thinking in metaphor is so central to our everyday experience that we barely notice it. But the metaphors we use in our thinking have a huge impact on how we live our lives. Our metaphors influence our actions Do you think of life a constant battle? Are you constantly
Compare and contrast
about 1 year ago - 1 comment
“People think in metaphor.” That’s a routine idea in cognitive science nowadays, and it’s pretty central to what I do. It’s so important that I’m constantly playing with new ways of making the same point. One that’s been working well recently is to say, “People think by comparing and contrasting things. “Whenever we encounter something new,










about 1 year ago
Posted this on FB, first, but don’t like facebook such much as a platform for more serious discussions, so here goes:
I like the idea that some gestures works both ways. However, since we are not machines, I remain a bit (more than a bit, in fact) sceptical, and worried about how this information (if it turns out to be more than the latest fad) can be abused in exploitative ways by people who don’t deserve our trust and who do not become so easily trustworthy simply by them making gestures in another plane…
about 1 year ago
PS Judy, i’m not surprized that this worked well… for you.
Because, unless I’m very mistaken, integrity is an essential value for you. And so, such a gesture would be congruent with this essential dimension of yours – and maybe a good reminder or anchor for that- and credible for your partners.
I wish I could say that of all negotiators…
about 1 year ago
Thanks for your confidence, Maarten!
I’m currently wondering whether “acting trustworthy” would actually be likely to MAKE someone more trustworthy – i.e. that the action actually influences the actor’s self-perception and thus changes their behaviour.
about 1 year ago
Fake it till you make it?
Doesn’t that depend on how much the “faking” is “fighting against” (perceptions that contradict the fake, feelings that contradict the fake)?
What if “acting trustworthy” also implies: “pretending you don’t want to exploit the other”?
How can we develop a quality without denying those tendencies in us that seem opposite of the quality?
But I guess you have something else in mind than “fake it till you make it”, such as actively eliciting the other person’s objections to your proposals.
There I’m with you – and with Linda Schneider.
about 1 year ago
To come back to the Truth-plane stuff:
Does making a gesture in the horizontal plane at the level of the navel increase the likelihood that the speaker better cailbrates signs of objections in the listener?
Frankly, I doubt it.
about 1 year ago
Hmm.
“Does making a gesture in the horizontal plane at the level of the navel increase the likelihood that the speaker better calilbrates signs of objections in the listener?”
I think it probably does. By making the “actor” feel calmer and more confident, it probably quietens their internal dialogue, at least to some extent, and therefore enables them to receive more feedback of all kinds. Whether they act on that feedback, of course, is up to them.
Mark’s background is in theatre, and now he’s in the business of coaching corporate speakers to convince big meetings of staff or shareholders, so he’s more on the “delivery” side.
What happens when you test this out for yourself, Maarten?
about 1 year ago
good question, Judy!
And…(as you’d say
it’s too soon to tell;
For now it is more distracting from the kind of calibration that we’re talking about than helping.
Another factor for me: having done tons of bodywork already – and being myopic (with a tendency to forget to look), cues for helping me to look outwards are more helpful for me than gestures that sends me kinestetic messages.
Didn’t realize this consciously, so thanks for asking!