minds, metaphors and (ethical) manipulation
Influence: actions speak louder than words
Influential language is important. Questions, listening and metaphor are important. But there could be an even more important factor in influence: the purely “incidental” behaviour of the people around you.
“Turns out your colleague’s husband’s sister can make you fat, even if you’ve never met. And a happy friend affects your happiness more than a bigger income. It turns out our connections – our friends, our friend’s friends, even our friends’ friends’ friends – have an astonishing influence on our behaviours, beliefs and even health.”
That’s the blurb from Connected by Nicholas Christakis and James Fowler, which sets out the science behind these surprising claims.
As I blogged recently, the infectious metaphors in people’s language, including their body language, provide one of the important ways in which behaviours spread through groups.
And there’s more to it than that.
Because behaviours can spread through networks of people even when there’s no intentional communication – and even no direct relationship – between the people involved.
Actions speak louder than words – and significantly louder than the small gestures which are generally thought of as “body language”.
Here’s an example. I live very close to the Brentford football ground and yesterday, the team was playing at Wembley.
At one level, Wembley is a west London suburb about five miles away from Brentford. But of course “Wembley” has a much greater metaphorical significance than that – playing there means “We’re in the cup final!”
From early morning the street was full of flag- and scarf-waving, singing fans, joyously preparing to travel to the game together in a convoy of buses and coaches.
Now, I can honestly say that I couldn’t care less about football, and I’m sure the fans couldn’t care less about me. There was no intention to communicate.
But my heart filled with pride for my “local” team and I was almost tearful as the convoy departed, taking my good wishes with it.
The fans’ celebration was massively infectious. Their “metaphors” – waving flags and scarves, singing, shouting excitedly and all the rest – had a profound emotional influence on me.
A combination of what they were saying (singing, shouting) and doing (waving things) had an impact on my emotions…
And here’s the thing. One specific thing they were doing (waiting in a bus) influenced me at a different level. If I’d wanted to drive anywhere, I couldn’t get the car out!
There’s influence, and there’s influence.
It ties to a comment by Tim Ferris in my other favourite book of the moment, The 4-Hour Body.
Internet marketing guru Eben Pagan (aka dating guru David DeAngelo) asked him in an interview: “What’s the fastest way for someone to improve their inner game?”
Tim replied: “Improve your outer game.”
He explains: “The Cartesian separation of mind and body is false. They’re reciprocal. Start with the precision of changing physical reality and a domino effect will often take care of the internal.”
Where will you start?
| Print article | This entry was posted by Judy on 04/04/2011 at 9:16 am, and is filed under Body-Mind, Influence, Metaphor. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |
What Is Clean Language?
about 5 months ago - 1 comment
I talk a lot about Clean Language on this blog. But you may be wondering what Clean Language is, and why it’s interesting. So (thanks to a nudge from a friend on Facebook) I’ve decided it’s time for a few short introductory YouTube videos. Here’s the first one: If you prefer to read your introduction,
Sacking The “Berlusconi Of The Brain”
about 6 months ago - 3 comments
Berlusconi no longer runs Italy. But is the “Berlusconi of the Brain” still in charge in your own world? According to Iain McGilchrist, the left hemisphere of the brain is like Berlusconi because it controls the media. It airbrushes reality, creating rational, linguistic arguments to generate an illusory perfect, mechanistic world. When you combine that
Do You Know The Right Answer?
about 6 months ago - 1 comment
How often do you ask a question to which you don’t know the answer? “Never!” is apparently the answer trial lawyers would give. Makes sense – they dont want a witness embarrassing them on the stand with something unexpected. But the rule seems to spread beyond the courtroom. At the Clean Business Exchange on Friday,
Breakthrough Sessions
about 7 months ago - 2 comments
If you were to have a “breakthrough session”, what kind of “breakthrough” would yours be? My friend James Tripp and I were talking yesterday about how various coaches and therapists offer “breakthrough sessions” – and I must have subconsciously asked myself: “What kind of breakthrough?” because a personal story sprang to mind. (James pointed out
“This will have a very profound effect”
about 8 months ago - No comments
Peter Wright’s very kind review of my brand-new video, The Mind Readers’ Guide To Metaphor Part 1: Hearing Hidden Metaphors, is below. Look out! The video will be published any day now. Sneak peek here Metaphor is all around us. And it’s our most widely used form of language born, as it is, out of
Clean Language: Hypnosis Without Trance?
about 10 months ago - 18 comments
My good friend James Tripp is riding high at the moment: his latest Hypnosis Without Trance product sold out in minutes! I knew James included lots of Clean Language ideas in his work. But I hadn’t spotted the references to “trance without induction” in David Grove’s only published book until I re-read on a flight it
The Perfect Elevator Pitch?
about 11 months ago - 8 comments
How much can a label such as “coach” or “mentor” say about you? My recent blog Call Yourself A Coach? promoted some interesting discussions, online and off. The consensus? Of course a label can’t say everything about you – because there’s more to you than the label. But my point was that labels aren’t just
Why Don’t You Ask More Questions?
about 11 months ago - No comments
Why don’t you ask more questions? It’s a question that’s been nagging me for a while, as I’ve been busy both exhorting people to do more asking – for example, in this video – and training people to ask specific kinds of questions. And (doh!) one possible answer has just struck me. Presumably, something’s stopping
Are Second-Hand Metaphors Restricting Your Life?
about 1 year ago - 4 comments
Are you living your life according to your own metaphors? Or is your system being restricted by ill-fitting second-hand ideas, images and connections? As I’ve mentioned frequently in this blog, the metaphors you use in your thinking (including your subconscious processing) have a profound impact on your behaviour. It’s inevitable, because metaphor is the language
How to get people to trust you
about 1 year ago - 7 comments
I’ve been blogging recently about the relationship between words, physical actions, metaphor and influence. One expert who really “gets” this, who I had the privilege of meeting recently, is Mark Bowden, author of Winning Body Language. Let me share my biggest takeaway from the many useful things he taught me. It’s something I started using










about 1 year ago
As we say in France “ça tombe à pic”, Judy.
In more prosaic words: your timing is excellent.
I was about to send you a mail wanting to explore with you in more details the link between exploring a person’s metaphorical landscapes and his/her actions in the “real” world…
Thanks, alors!
Maarten