minds, metaphors and (ethical) manipulation
Frame control – the power of context
Great influencers have long recognised the power of setting the context of any conversation. For example, pick-up artists discuss “frame control” and assert that “In an interaction between two people, whoever has the stronger frame/reality wins”.
Of course, I don’t accept their win-lose frame! Influential interactions can be, and in my opinion should be, win-win, especially in the context of sexual relationships.
But I do agree that setting the context of any interaction is very important, and that once the frame is set, it can be very difficult for either party to escape from it.
A colleague said recently: “The first thing anyone wants to know when they visit a website is ‘what can I buy here?’” But that’s only true if the frame is “website = commercial resource”.
If, on the other hand, the frame is “website = research resource” then the instant question is more like “what can I discover here?” If the frame is “website = social resource” then the question is “who can I meet here?”
One of the most important ways people set frames is by using metaphors. I might want you to think of my website as like a shop, or as like a library, or as like a cafe. And so great web designers use language, graphics, images etc to deliberately bring the relevant metaphor to life, so that visitors automatically and immediately grasp the frame of the interaction. (I’ll write more about this in a future post.)
But it’s equally important to note that we can’t not set frames. In Clean Language we aim to minimise the use of frame-setting assumptions and presuppositions in our questions – but the conversation still takes place within a frame, a context. The original context of Clean Language was always a psychotherapy session, or a training workshop for therapists. Later it was used in the context of coaching sessions. People arrive to take part in these conversations with a fairly solid frame already in place.
I contend that Clean Language can be very valuable within other contexts, such as sales. And in these contexts, the Intelligent Influencer pays attention to setting an appropriate frame for an interaction. Marketing materials are awash with metaphors, assumptions and presuppositions, whether we are aware of them or not: I think that being aware of them opens the door to using them more purposefully and more effectively.
After all, we can’t not set contexts, and we can’t not respond to them.
Iain McGilchrist in The Master And His Emissary puts it well: “The nature of the attention one brings to bear on anything alters what one finds; what we aim to understand changes its nature with the context in which it lies… we cannot see something without a context, even if the context appears to be that of ‘no context’, a thing ripped from its moorings in the lived world. That is just a special, highly value-laden kind of context in itself, and it certainly alters what we find, too.”
| Print article | This entry was posted by Judy on 30/12/2010 at 11:25 am, and is filed under Clean Language, Influence, Metaphor, Posts, The Mind. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |
What Is Clean Language?
about 5 months ago - 1 comment
I talk a lot about Clean Language on this blog. But you may be wondering what Clean Language is, and why it’s interesting. So (thanks to a nudge from a friend on Facebook) I’ve decided it’s time for a few short introductory YouTube videos. Here’s the first one: If you prefer to read your introduction,
Breakthrough Sessions
about 7 months ago - 2 comments
If you were to have a “breakthrough session”, what kind of “breakthrough” would yours be? My friend James Tripp and I were talking yesterday about how various coaches and therapists offer “breakthrough sessions” – and I must have subconsciously asked myself: “What kind of breakthrough?” because a personal story sprang to mind. (James pointed out
How to get people to trust you
about 1 year ago - 7 comments
I’ve been blogging recently about the relationship between words, physical actions, metaphor and influence. One expert who really “gets” this, who I had the privilege of meeting recently, is Mark Bowden, author of Winning Body Language. Let me share my biggest takeaway from the many useful things he taught me. It’s something I started using
Who’s making you fat – and how?
about 1 year ago - 1 comment
Your colleague’s husband’s sister can apparently make you fat, even if you’ve never met. But how does that happen? In Connected, Nicholas Christakis and James Fowler explain that there are two main ways that people may influence each other. By changing what you do… and By changing what you think. My focus has mainly been on how
Influence: actions speak louder than words
about 1 year ago - 2 comments
Influential language is important. Questions, listening and metaphor are important. But there could be an even more important factor in influence: the purely “incidental” behaviour of the people around you. “Turns out your colleague’s husband’s sister can make you fat, even if you’ve never met. And a happy friend affects your happiness more than a
Infectious metaphors
about 1 year ago - 6 comments
As I mentioned recently, the habit of thinking in metaphor is so central to our everyday experience that we barely notice it. But the metaphors we use in our thinking have a huge impact on how we live our lives. Our metaphors influence our actions Do you think of life a constant battle? Are you constantly
Compare and contrast
about 1 year ago - 1 comment
“People think in metaphor.” That’s a routine idea in cognitive science nowadays, and it’s pretty central to what I do. It’s so important that I’m constantly playing with new ways of making the same point. One that’s been working well recently is to say, “People think by comparing and contrasting things. “Whenever we encounter something new,
How to use questions in sales
about 1 year ago - No comments
I blogged recently about the magic of questions – about their hypnotic power to direct people’s attention in specific ways. All quite interesting, my readers thought. But how, they asked, can this knowledge be applied, in real, practical terms? One way is to use questions to take people into particular emotional states, by focussing their
The magic of questions
about 1 year ago - 1 comment
Have you ever noticed how magical questions can be? And have you ever wondered how that works? Whenever we are asked a question, we instantly search for an answer: it’s almost a reflex action. And that gives questions – and questioners – phenomenal power. Because by asking the right kind of questions, you can direct
How to make an awesome sales pitch
about 1 year ago - 1 comment
My good friend Jamie Smart delivered the best sales pitch I’ve ever seen this weekend. It was, quite frankly, awesome – and I’ve seen a lot of them. It was within a weekend workshop on “Getting Clients Congruently”, which was also excellent*. But it was the sales pitch itself that had the greatest impact for










about 1 year ago
Great post Judy – and very thought provoking. I’m with you on the win-win frame since not every interaction is a contest; rather more a context.
A couple of trains of thought seem to arrive on cue here…..
And in terms of context, this where good comedians are masters of the context of the frame. I increasingly find myself not so much laughing at good comedians but marvelling at the (often) exquisite nature of their frames and contexts.
Another thought came to mind about the random and often bizarre nature of certain threads within dreams – inasmuchas here we unconsciously present frames and contexts that in conscious recall are seemingly “ripped from their moorings”.
The conventional dream interpreter endeavours to place some stable meaning upon these aimlessly drifting notions, usually imposing their own reality however.
Using Clean Language to draw a person into their unconcscious metaphoric landscape seems rather akin to reversing the interpretive tools to elicit the ‘dream’, thus framing the landscape as an appropriate vehicle for positive outcome.
Thanks for kindling this area for me!
about 1 year ago
There’s another slant on these fascinating and essential ideas: that the meaphors the client select can also be as it were an illustration of how the “metaphorizing person” perceives his context, incluiding the person he is interviewing.
Psychoanalyst Robert Langs puts it this way: “the images etc. that the patient reports are also an indirect commentary on the transference and the therapeutic frame”.
This perspective is IMO not relevant for short-term coaching sessions, but in more intensive and longterm relationships it may be something to consider…
about 1 year ago
oho, typo again: I mean of course: “the person he is interviewed by.”
about 1 year ago
Thanks for the comments guys! You might also be interested in this post by my friend Wayne Marsh: http://www.umamiuk.com/2010/12/the-metaphor-of-power/
about 1 year ago
I was sceptical at first but after reading your report and seeing some of your work on youtube I think you are a Legend Judy. And that stuff about parroting what they say back to them is absolutely Amazing. You Really Know Your Stuff.
Thanks Judy and Rock On
about 1 year ago
Hi Judy,
as always judy, n i c e. Win win practices bring to the fore exciting results. Your libaray shop social gathering space metaphors,corresponds nicely, informs as im writing this years business plans to include opportunities to confer, runs deeper than cook book mushroom stuffing to financial managment, the core of business success. When metaphors do their stuff, they pack a lot in,t With xray listenig,theres that potential,to make Futures Now.
happy new year