minds, metaphors and (ethical) manipulation
Humpty Dumpty definitions and what you can do about them
Welcome! If you're interested in how people think, click to get The X-Ray Listener's Quick Guide To Metaphor and unlock a new perspective on the mind... for free.
Why can’t people just say what they mean? Ambiguity and confusion, resulting in wasted effort, frayed tempers, and increased costs, are common in all business environments.
Misunderstandings can be bad enough when you’re face-to-face with colleagues – but the problem gets even worse when technological, linguistic and cultural communication barriers are added to the mix.
If you have a sense that everyone you talk to has a different understanding of the crucial definitions or terms on your project – you’re right!
Language is a wonderfully flexible tool. But its very flexibility leads to problems: everyone thinks they’re like Humpty Dumpty, and can use words to mean whatever they choose them to mean!
For example, if you ask two people to think of a tree, then check the details of the tree they thought of, you’ll discover that no two people’s trees are ever exactly the same. It’s not that one is right and one is wrong – it’s just that they are different.
And the more novel or complex the topic, the greater the scope for differences of meaning.
When it’s your job to sort out these differences, to achieve a consensus of meaning, then here’s an X-Ray Listening tip. Make extra time to listen, carefully, to the words each person uses to define the term at issue. If you’re taking notes (particularly notes they can see, such as on a whiteboard), write down their actual words. And when you ask clarifying questions, use those words in your questions.
People’s words are important to them and again, contain nuances of meaning that are specific to each individual. Using a person’s own words back to them helps them to feel heard and respected.
And once they know that they’ve been heard, they’ll be in a better frame of mind to listen themselves. They’ll take more notice of what others have to say – and ultimately, more likely to agree to your proposal for a new, consensus definition.
- This issue was at the heart of a 90-minute training session I shared with my new “phone mastermind group” last night. This training is something I’ve delivered many times with face-to-face groups – now I’ve demonstrated that it can work well with a small group on the phone. If your company might find this valuable, please get in touch for a no-obligation discussion – call +44(0)7979 495509
| Print article | This entry was posted by Judy on 20/01/2010 at 4:32 pm, and is filed under Listening, Posts. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |
No comments yet.
Getting results from really listening
about 1 year ago - 1 comment
When you really listen, what results do you get? You might be pleasantly surprised. In a recent post I suggested you try a “two-minute listen” with a good friend or family member. Did you try it? If so, what happened? Students on my online learning programme tried it out recently. At first, some had struggled.
Are you a good listener? How do you know?
about 1 year ago - 2 comments
Are you a good listener? Whether you think you are or not – how would you know? It’s slightly alarming to realise that if you’re NOT a good listener, you probably won’t be aware of that fact! As James Borg points out in his bestselling book Persuasion, it’s one of those things that people are often criticised
The great trick of public speaking
about 1 year ago - No comments
I wonder, have you ever considered buying a book or a course on public speaking? That’s something a lot of people do – and there’s a less-than-obvious reason for it. As I mentioned in my recent report, Seven Intelligent Ways to Influence and Persuade, many sales and persuasion trainers put the cart before the horse.
The 2 Lazy Jedi questions and the NLP Meta Model
about 1 year ago - No comments
If you’re familiar with NLP before you encounter the 2 Lazy Jedi questions (which are based on David Grove’s Clean Language) you might wonder about the relationship between these questions and an NLP questioning system, the Meta Model. The two systems are similar in a couple of ways: that they are questioning systems, for example,
Why it pays to use their words
about 1 year ago - 5 comments
The new coalition government in the UK uses a different language to its predecessor. Of course, it’s still English – and it’s still packed with jargon! But according to a leaked memo, there have been subtle changes. “Targets” have been replaced by “results”; “stakeholders” by “people”; “narrowing the gap” by “closing the gap”; “state” by
Listening, attention and fortune-telling
about 2 years ago - No comments
What happens when you pay someone exquisite attention? It seems to me that the effects can be truly “magical”. A few months ago, my partner had his running gait analysed by someone on an exhibition stand. The guy used a battery of gizmos, but central to his approach was attention – he worked with Steve
Harnessing the power of your attention
about 2 years ago - No comments
I wonder if you realise just how valuable your attention can be? As Nancy Kline puts it: “The quality of your attention determines the quality of other people’s thinking.” If you’re an expert in a particular subject, it’s easy to believe that people pay you for your expertise, your knowledge, your advice. But in fact
How to become a Chief Listening Officer
about 2 years ago - No comments
Organisations are slowly waking up to the need to increase listening at all levels. The big question is not whether to do so, but how. In a recent article in Forbes magazine went straight to the heart of the issue. John Ryan wrote: “We need to be the chief listening officers in our organizations –
The joy of listening
about 2 years ago - No comments
One of the best things about listening is the pleasure it brings – both to the person being listened to, and to the listener. There’s a real joy for me in eliciting new information: information that my interviewee didn’t know they knew. People are absolutely fascinating, once you get beyond the everyday conversational niceties and
Quieten the voice inside
about 2 years ago - No comments
What distracts you from listening fully to another person? For many people, it’s the ‘voice inside’ – their own internal commentator. This voice may be distracting for all kinds of reasons – it might be offering useful-sounding suggestions, putting forward opinions, criticising, or even talking about something completely different, such as “what’s for supper?” But
